Tuesday, February 19, 2008

A DOCTOR STRUGGLES WITH ANOREXIA & OSTEOPOROSIS...



In my reading about anorexia and its relationship to starvation diets, I came across the following article about a doctor whose health has been forever deleteriously impacted as a result of a diet she was on for only 18 months.


For those following the deadly Kimkins starvation diet, as well as any other very low calorie diet (VLCD), please heed Dr. Richman's warning.


"'Dieting ruined my health'

Jane Elliott
BBC News Online health staff


Anna still suffers from side effects


An eating disorder in her teens left Dr. Anna Richman with a legacy of ill-health.


Aged only 32, Anna has osteoporosis - a condition usually associated with menopausal women twice her age.

Formerly a statuesque six footer Anna, used to be taller than her sisters, but the osteoporosis has taken at least two inches from her height.

"The irony is that I wanted to lose weight to have a better-shaped body.

"When I lost the height from my spine my waist actually disappeared and I was left with a protruding stomach.

"I will never get that height back. It seems to have gone from the top half of my body and it affects the way I dress."

As well as osteoporosis, anorexia can have further drastic effects on the body.

A lack of food deprives the body of protein and prevents the normal metabolism of fat.

The effects of this can include an irregular heart beat caused by a change in the heart muscle - which in turn can lead to heart failure and death.

Other problems can include ceasing of menstruation, dehydration, kidney stones and kidney failure.

Some anorexics also develop a fine, downy body hair, called lanugo, on the face and arms and their muscles waste away. Some suffer constipation or bowel irritation.

Teenage diet

Anna, who now works as a hospital doctor in Liverpool, started to diet in her late teens.


"I was only dieting for 18 months, but the implications have gone on for years," she said.

It wasn't long after Anna started dieting that her weight got out of control.

Very soon she was hospitalised with anorexia.

"It did just start off as a bit of a diet. I lost a bit of weight and then it went from a diet to anorexia."

When Anna was first hospitalised her weight had plummeted to just seven-and-a-half stone.

Doctors helped her build her weight back up to over 10 stone.

But then she relapsed and needed hospitalisation as it slumped again to just six stone.

Rebuilding life

Watching her friends leave her behind as they gained their A' Levels and then university places, Anna struggled to take charge of her life again.

She took her exams and started to study medicine, but the damage had been done.

"When I was 19 I was just getting over the anorexia and had taken a part-time job in a nursing home.

"I had a backache and was just told that everyone at the home used to get these.

"But then one day I was in excruciating pain with my back and I just fell to the floor. I could not walk and had to crawl back to bed."


Eventually doctors diagnosed Anna with osteoporosis and spotted that she had two compression fractures in the spine.

Her bone density was low and doctors recommended a high-dose pill to boost her levels.

But she found taking calcium tablets and doing weight bearing exercises worked better.

Fragile bones

Emma Burrows, of the National Osteoporosis Society, said young women like Anna are at an increased risk of osteoporosis.

"Oestrogen is essential for healthy bones in women. Over-dieting can cause a drop in oestrogen levels similar to that experienced at the menopause and can result in fragile bones that are liable to break easily.

"It is essential that we all protect our bones by eating a healthy, well-balanced and calcium rich diet, and that doesn't mean it has to be fattening.

"Low-fat dairy products, such as skimmed milk, actually contain more calcium than the full-fat varieties, and calcium can come from non-dairy sources too.

"Young women who miss their periods for six months or more as a result of over-dieting or over-exercising are at an increased risk of suffering a broken bone due to osteoporosis and should talk to their GP about a possible bone scan or treatment."


Risks


One in three woman and one in 12 men over 50 have osteoporosis

Treating broken bones due to osteoporosis costs the NHS about £5 million a day "


~~~~~

LINK: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/2936201.stm

Follow on Buzz

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

Fascinating reading! I wish there were some way to get a copy of this into the hands of every member of Kimkins.com!

2BIG said...

thanks for blogging about this aspect of VLCDs. Something for all kimkineets to think about.

2BIG

BamaGal said...

This is sad.

No one knows the extent of the long term complications of following a diet can be. It makes me feel for all the former Kimkins followers. What do other complications do they have facing them further down the road?

Thanks for sharing this with us Medusa. You are awesome as usual.

OhYeahBabe said...

That is so startling! I pray that people will see that even short term dieting can do permanent - yes PERMANENT - harm. I really hope that this shows people who criticize dieters for going to extremes that it's an error that can be made by anyone, and they may not even be aware they are making it until the symptoms start to show.
OYB
My blog: Kimorexia

Kerry said...

I knew a severe anorexic in high school who is now a healthy heart surgeon of all things. She seems to be one of the few without too much permanent damage--but I don't know her well enough to really say. I have suffered from EDs and so much of the damage--physical, emotional, spiritual--is long-term. Starving a body is like taking away water from a flower ready to blossom or already in bloom. I wish I KNEW then what I know now. I knew it but didn't really know it. Thanks for the great postings all and especially to the site's host. This site has the right message that so many need.

Kerry said...

I knew a severe anorexic in high school who is now a healthy heart surgeon of all things. She seems to be one of the few without too much permanent damage--but I don't know her well enough to really say. I have suffered from EDs and so much of the damage--physical, emotional, spiritual--is long-term. Starving a body is like taking away water from a flower ready to blossom or already in bloom. I wish I KNEW then what I know now. I knew it but didn't really know it. Thanks for the great postings all and especially to the site's host. This site has the right message that so many need.

Medusa said...

Kerry, thanks so much for your very kind comments.

~ Medusa

Jinhong (aka.Scarlet) said...

My diet turned into anorexia last year, and it was only for 6 months but here I am, with serious hypotension, constipation, chronic headache, bloated stomach, flat breasts, and more. I'm still stuck in the binge-restrict cycle and I know this lifestyle is lethal and I really want to change it but I still see a fat cow in the mirror. I don't know what to do, both mind and the body. Please, those of you who want to stop eating, don't. Listen to us. Don't.

Medusa said...

((Jinhong (aka.Scarlet))

Thanks for commenting.

I am so sorry to hear you're struggling so. I hope that you're able to get professional help to help you regain your health.

Sending hugs your way,

Medusa

Anonymous said...

The problem isn't the patients, it's the doctors.
I (and many others) have been told that they will do something if my weight goes down. That's fucking hilarious to tell someone who wants to lose weight but is trying to be normal. Or who has made themselves very very sick but then gets told that if they would be just a little sicker, they could see that there was a problem, but as such, the fact you are starving yourself is okay, because you do not use laxatives. (presumably this means you don't have a "real" eating disorder)